Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Nature, agency, and the nature of agency

Kenneth Walden


I examine skeptical arguments about the constitutive nature of agency, with special attention to those of Elijah Millgram. I suggest that these arguments lead us not to the conclusion that agency has no such nature, but that it is an essentially contested kind in the same way that art is. I argue that this undermines traditional forms of constitutivism in metaethics but opens the door to a different way of pursuing the same program. Finally, I take issue with Millgram’s solution to the problem of “logical aliens” and suggest an alternative based my analogy with art.


agency; practical reason; constitutivism; art; Elijah Millgram;

Full Text:




  • There are currently no refbacks.